SUBMISSION & INITIAL SCREENING
- Author submits the manuscript to the JEHS.
- Managing Editor checks formatting and compliance with author guidelines.
- If formatting is incorrect → manuscript is returned to the author for corrections.
DESK REVIEW
- Manuscript is forwarded to the Chief Editor & Editor for desk review.
- If found unsuitable → Manuscript Rejected.
- If it passes desk review → sent to the Section Editor
ASSIGNMENTS TO EDITORS
- Section editor reviews the manuscript.
- Manuscript may be:
- Assigned to a Biostatistician for statistical review (if required).
- Assigned to a Statistical Editor for quality assurance of statistical review.
- If found unsuitable at this stage → Manuscript Rejected.
INTERNAL EDITORIAL REVIEW
- Internal review completed; editor may request revisions from the author.
- Manuscript sent back to author for corrections.
- After successful revisions → manuscript is cleared for external peer review.
EXTERNAL EDITORIAL REVIEW
- Manuscript is sent to external reviewer(s) for peer review.
- Reviewers submit comments to the section editor.
- Editor evaluates reviewer comments and decides whether:
- Further review is needed
- Or decision can be made
AUTHORS REVISIONS
- Based on reviewer/editor comments, manuscript may be sent to the author for revisions.
- Author submits the revised version.
EDITORIAL DECISION
- Section editor completes decision based on reviews and revisions.
- Manuscript forwarded to the Chief Editor for final decision.
FINAL DECISION BY CHIEF EDITOR / EDITOR
- Chief Editor/ Editor reviews all reports and recommendations.
- Final outcome:
- Manuscript Accepted
- Manuscript Rejected